I’ve been making Witch’s Brew for years now, and every time Halloween rolls around, my friends start asking when it’s coming back. I still remember the first time I whipped up a batch for my annual costume party – there were witches, zombies, pirates, and somehow, everyone kept coming back to the kitchen “for just one more glass.” I’d planned to make them individually, but after a few rounds, I admitted defeat and switched to mixing it all up in my biggest punch bowl. (Let’s be honest, it looked pretty magical in there – even if I wish I could call it a cauldron.)
What I love most about this drink is how festive it looks: a wickedly bright green, fizzy, and tart-sweet. The key is the fresh lime juice (it makes all the difference), paired with crisp apple cider and a hit of ginger ale for that playful sparkle. And don’t worry – despite the mysterious color, it’s perfectly family-friendly if you leave out the alcohol.
Strength & Profile
Note: You can tap on flavors, occasions, and feels to view more similar cocktail recipes.
It’s a staple in my house every October, though I’ve been known to pull it out for summer parties too. For big Halloween bashes, I even set up a “brewing station” with dry ice for that dramatic, bubbling effect – always a crowd-pleaser (especially with the kids). If you’re feeling extra, you can even rim the glasses with black sugar for that witchy vibe.
Witch’s Brew Ingredients
- 4 ounces apple cider
- 1 ounce fresh lime juice
- 3 ounces ginger ale
- A few drops of green food coloring
- Ice cubes
- (Optional) 1.5 oz vodka or white rum for the grown-ups
- Garnish: lime slice or apple wedge
I almost always serve this in mason jars or clear pint glasses – the color is too good to hide! If you want to make it super Halloween-y, dip the rim in juice and then in black sugar for a spookier effect.
Mixing Up the Magic
- Fill a cocktail shaker with ice.
- Pour in the apple cider and fresh lime juice.
- Add a few drops of green food coloring. (You can always add a little more later; it doesn’t take much!)
- Shake well, about 10–15 seconds, until it’s chilly and mixed.
- Fill your glass with fresh ice and strain the brew in.
- Top with ginger ale, and stir gently.
- Garnish with a lime slice or wedge of apple.
Honestly, it takes less than a minute to make – a lifesaver when you’re juggling party snacks and a front door full of trick-or-treaters. Seriously: don’t skimp on the fresh lime juice. It makes the flavors really pop.
Food-wise, I like to keep things simple with a Halloween cheese board – something sharp like cheddar or gouda works so well with the crisp, lightly sweet cocktail. Spicy chips or roasted nuts are a hit too; the drink is just sweet enough to balance out the salt.
Variations for the Adventurous
- Red Witch’s Brew: Swap the apple cider for cranberry juice and use a few drops of red food coloring for a bold twist.
- Less Sweet: Replace the ginger ale with sparkling water or seltzer for a more subtle, drier version.
- Minty Witch’s Brew: Muddle in a few fresh mint leaves before shaking. It’s unexpectedly refreshing – lime and mint just work!
For parties, I usually make a big pitcher or punch bowl, leaving out the ginger ale until right before serving, so each glass keeps its bubbles.
Whether you’re throwing the loudest costume party on the block, or just feeling festive on a random Saturday, this Witch’s Brew never disappoints. Don’t be surprised when everyone asks for the recipe – or when you find yourself making a double batch next time!
