For decades, there’s been this strange, delightful cocktail quietly traded among bartenders and night owls – a drink that somehow winds coffee, cream, cola, and vodka together into something you can’t quite explain but can’t stop sipping. I bumped into this oddball recipe years ago, late one rainy Thursday in a sticky-floored Chicago dive. The bartender called it a “Smith and Wesson” – a name he claimed was for its sneaky kick, though it sounded just as much like an inside joke between regulars.
This isn’t one you’ll find in the dusty old cocktail books or scribbled on chalkboards at boutique lounges. Instead, it lingers among those of us who want something creamy and caffeinated, with a nod toward soda-fountain nostalgia and a little grown-up fire. It’s like a White Russian dressed up for a soda shop date, or a Colorado Bulldog with better stories.
Strength & Profile
Note: You can tap on flavors, occasions, and feels to view more similar cocktail recipes.
I’ve lost count of the times I’ve tried to nail the recipe at home. Some nights I got it right, the flavors cozy and balanced. More than once, though, I wound up with a glass of something my friends nicknamed “coffee mud” – usually delivered with a sympathetic pat on the shoulder. Still, every now and then, you hit that sweet spot: rich, fizzy, just sweet enough, and a perfect bridge between dessert and a nightcap.
Here’s How I Make Mine:
- 1 oz coffee liqueur (honestly, Kahlúa is the go-to)
- 1 oz vodka (save the good stuff for sipping neat)
- 1 oz heavy cream
- 2 oz cola (Mexican Coke if you can find it – real sugar makes a difference)
- Ice cubes
- Optional: a cherry or a twist of lemon peel, if you’re feeling fancy
Grab a highball glass if you have one, but I’ve tossed these together just as happily in juice glasses or whatever’s on hand after the dishwasher’s run.
To put it together:
- Fill your glass with fresh ice – the frozen mystery lumps from the back of the freezer just water it down.
- Pour in the coffee liqueur, then the vodka.
- Slowly pour the cream over the back of a spoon so it floats on top. (Sometimes I nail the layered effect, sometimes it all swirls together. Either way – delicious.)
- Top off with the cola, pouring gently so it doesn’t fizz over.
- Give the whole thing a gentle stir to blend, but don’t go crazy – you want some of that creamy drift.
I once tried making an alcohol-free version for a friend, using cold brew concentrate and a splash of vanilla syrup in place of the booze. It wasn’t quite the same thing, but it hit the spot all the same – smooth, a little decadent, perfect for a slow afternoon.
When I first whipped up a batch for poker night, they were gone faster than anyone could fold a bad hand. Mike, who usually brings his own six-pack and ignores my “weird drinks,” ended up writing the recipe down on a cocktail napkin. He still sends me blurry photos whenever he makes one, usually alongside a stack of pretzel crumbs.
A couple of things I’ve learned over time: Use good coffee liqueur; it matters way more than your choice of vodka. Whole cream gives the most velvety texture – half-and-half works in a pinch, but it’s never quite the same. And don’t overlook the cola; real sugar versions make the flavors pop in a way diet sodas just can’t.
This drink loves company. Salty snacks like pretzels or nuts seem to make it even more moreish. Pair it with chocolate? You might not need dessert.
There are endless tweaks. Some nights I’ll shake in cinnamon or swirl a finger of amaretto if I’m feeling indulgent. Over the holidays, I’ve been known to sneak in a dash of peppermint extract for an offbeat, festive kick. For lighter days, I use light cream and diet cola, but let’s be honest – it loses its magic when you tone it down too much.
Is it classy? Not especially. But it’s comfort in a glass, especially when you want something that blurs the line between cocktail and dessert, or just want a break from the usual. Maybe don’t plan an early start the next day, though – the coffee liqueur might perk you up, but the vodka has other ideas.
