I spent last weekend hosting a few friends for an evening that was supposed to be a laid-back hangout, but ended up turning into a little cocktail adventure. On a whim, I mixed Kahlúa with some fresh lemon juice, not at all sure what to expect. It turned out so good, I ended up making several rounds of Kahlúa Sours, and everyone kept asking for the recipe.
Admittedly, the idea of mixing coffee liqueur with citrus sounds weird – I thought so, too. But the rich, velvety notes of Kahlúa with that punchy brightness of lemon really balance each other out. Now, I crave this drink whenever I want something more interesting than my usual bourbon or G&T.
Strength & Profile
Note: You can tap on flavors, occasions, and feels to view more similar cocktail recipes.
Most people know Kahlúa for classics like the White Russian, or maybe in a mudslide, but this sour twist deserves way more attention. There’s something about the contrast – the Kahlúa suddenly transforms from creamy, dessert-y coffee to something totally refreshing, and honestly, kind of addictive. You get all that roasty flavor cut with a tart edge, so it’s perfect year-round (not just for after-dinner in December).
I’ve fiddled around with the recipe over several evenings. The key, in my opinion, is to let the coffee taste shine, but give it enough citrus to really make it pop. If you overdo the lemon, it feels a bit harsh; too little, and you just get creamy syrup.
Here’s my favorite version:
—
Ingredients:
- 2 oz Kahlúa
- 1 oz fresh lemon juice (seriously, squeeze it yourself – the bottled stuff won’t cut it)
- ½ oz simple syrup
- 1 egg white (optional, but worth it for the texture)
- Ice
- Lemon twist or a couple of coffee beans (for garnish)
Glassware:
I usually reach for a rocks glass with a big chunk of ice, but if you’re fancy and want something elegant, a coupe works too (no ice needed). Sometimes I’ll even use whatever glass is clean.
—
How to Make It:
- Toss the Kahlúa, lemon juice, simple syrup, and egg white (if using) into a shaker.
- If you’re using egg white, start with a “dry shake” – shake everything without ice for about 15 seconds to work up the foam.
- Add ice and shake it hard until the shaker feels super cold – another 20 seconds or so.
- Strain into your chosen glass (over fresh ice if it’s a rocks glass, or just straight up into a coupe).
- Twist a lemon peel over the top for aromatic drama – or plop in a coffee bean or two if you want that café vibe.
—
The first time I made this with egg white, I hesitated, sure my guests would ask what the heck was floating on top. But that silky, cloud-like foam totally makes the drink. If raw egg whites freak you out, swap in a tablespoon or two of aquafaba (the liquid from canned chickpeas). It might sound odd, but I promise, you can’t taste it, and it still creates a proper foam.
Pairing-wise: try it with a dark chocolate square (like 70% cocoa), and you’ll see what I mean about bringing out those coffee notes. I’ve also set out bowls of salty Marcona almonds alongside these cocktails – they’re gone in minutes.
One night I was out of lemons and used lime juice instead. Different, but no less delicious: a little brighter, maybe even more refreshing. That’s officially become my summer riff.
For extra flair, I’ve tinkered with a dash of orange bitters or a splash of amaretto – a friend even throws in a sprinkle of cinnamon on top, which adds a gentle heat in the background.
What surprised me most is how unexpected and approachable this drink is. People see Kahlúa and assume it’s going to be sticky-sweet, but when you serve it like this, it’s suddenly vibrant, light, with enough intrigue that it always starts a conversation. These days, it’s my favorite thing to serve when I want guests to try something completely new but not too out there.
If you’re a coffee lover itching to try something different, or just searching for a well-balanced cocktail, give the Kahlúa Sour a shot. And fair warning: you’ll probably find yourself replenishing your Kahlúa stash more often once you realize how much more it can do than just spike your coffee.
